Squirtle

Cold Flare · #12/59 · Common · 2012JPN

$10.00

Market price ▲ 0.0% (1Y)

Prices as of Jul 26, 2026

Unlimited 1st Edition

73graded pop

60%gem rate

8.1×PSA 10 vs raw

-56%off ATH $6.74 · Mar 2023

+$18.51EV to grade — marginal

Printings & price history

Unlimited▲ 0.0% 7d$10.00

Low $5.95Mid $7.98High $10.00

Loading chart…

Buy it now on eBay

Loading live listings…

Live from eBay · affiliate links support CardPrice · see recent sold results →

Shop live eBay listings →Recent eBay sold results

Graded values

updated 2026-07-26

Grade 6 est.$2.79

Grade 5 est.$2.35

Grade 4 est.$1.94

Grade 3 est.$1.62

Grade 2 est.$1.32

Grade 1 est.$1.12

Grades 1–6 are estimates modeled from the raw price — PSA/CGC/BGS 7–10 and Ungraded are live tracked market values.

PSA 10 price history$80.50

PSA 10 chart is building — graded values are tracked nightly, a new point appears each day.

Graded population census · updated 2026-07-07

PSA14 graded · 10 gem 10

12345678910

CGC6 graded · 4 gem 10

12345678910

Population data from PriceCharting, updated monthly.

How much is Squirtle #12/59 worth?

Right now (July 26, 2026) the going rate for an ungraded Squirtle #12/59 from Cold Flare is about $10.00. Across the 2 printings we track, copies run anywhere from $5.50 to $10.00 depending on the version you're holding.

Grading changes the math on this one: a PSA 10 is valued around $80.50, roughly 8.1x the raw price, while a PSA 9 sits near $12.57. 36 copies have been graded to date, and 58% of them came back a 10 — worth knowing before you pay grading fees.

Prices on this page refresh nightly from live TCGplayer market data and are cross-checked against actual sold prices, so a single inflated listing never becomes "the price". The chart above has the full history.