The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow
Whispers in the Well · #125/204 · Legendary · 2025
Printings & price history
Loading chart…
Buy it now on eBay
Ad disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, CardPrice earns from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.
Loading live listings…
Live from eBay · affiliate links support CardPrice · see recent sold results →
How much is The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow #125/204 worth?
Right now (November 12, 2026) the going rate for an ungraded The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow #125/204 from Whispers in the Well is about $5.02. Across the 2 printings we track, copies run anywhere from $3.74 to $64.99 depending on the version you're holding.
Prices on this page refresh nightly from live TCGplayer market data and are cross-checked against actual sold prices, so a single inflated listing never becomes "the price". The chart above has the full history.